Sunday, May 26, 2013

148. Angelina's decision and some issues

I read with interest Angelina Jolie's op-ed article in the New York Times where she gave some details of and reasons for the double mastectomy she underwent recently. Her 56- year old mother had died of cancer and could not live long enough to carry all her grandchildren in her arms. Angelina found that she had a gene that could cause breast and ovarian cancer. Her doctors told her that she faced  87 % risk of breast cancer and 50% of ovarian cancer. By removing her breasts, she has cut down the risk of breast cancer to below 5%. The medical procedures took 3 months to be completed. At the end of it, she is happy that breast cancer is not likely to snatch her away from her children.

Angelina's step has been widely hailed as courageous and she has come to symbolise a woman who can take unorthodox decisions which she believes are in her interest. It has inspired women, particularly in countries like ours where women are not able to take even the most basic decisions pertaining to them. Many are not given the option to decide about their education, marriage, job and so on.

However, I am concerned by the report that doctors in Bangalore have been flooded with inquiries about double mastectomy. I hope, women take their own decisions after careful thinking and are not unduly influenced by what Angelina has done. Icons like Angelina can lead people to blindly follow them and take decisions which they may subsequently regret.

Removal of breasts for women anywhere can be traumatic. I am not sure if the risk is worth taking. Even after double mastectomy, the risk is not totally gone. It is only substantially reduced. Also, this is a risk that can be identified and quantified through some medical tests, but there are risks which cannot be identified. Since they cannot be identified, we cannot do anything about them. Does it really make sense to take such drastic preventive actions against the risks we are able to identify? I can understand going in for some vaccination and taking some medicine to prevent diseases from occurring, but double mastectomy is a totally different cup of tea.

I  understand that breast cancer may be cured if detected early. As per a WHO report, over 4,50,000 women die of breast cancer every year and most of them are from low income and middle income countries. For such women,a test to identify the gene which causes cancer is out of question. In India, the test is stated to be available only at Bangalore and costs about 80000 rupees. Many of these 4,50,000 women could have been saved if their breast cancer had been detected early, if they had been taught the techniques of self examination and if low-cost or free treatment had been made available to them. 

I respect Angelina's decision and appreciate the logic of it, but I hope and pray that her decision does not take the focus away from what I believe are the real issues.


तुषार राज रस्तोगी said...

बहुत ही सुन्दर और सशक्त लेखनी | पढ़कर अच्छा लगा | सादर आभार |

कभी यहाँ भी पधारें और लेखन भाने पर अनुसरण अथवा टिपण्णी के रूप में स्नेह प्रकट करने की कृपा करें |

Kumar Radharaman said...

Ladies are not all about breasts. Life goes beyond.

Anonymous said...

Dear blogger friend,

We take this opportunity to inform you that your blog has been listed in the Directory of Best Indian Blog, 2012-13 edition. [The announcement can be seen here.]

We have been bringing out this Directory since 2011 and the present one is its third edition.

If you are hearing of ITB for the first time and are curious about it, you might like to see our blog selection criteria and the process we follow for selecting blogs for this Directory.

We don't know how much you care for your blog’s listing, but we assure you that we work hard to select blogs for the Directory. ITB badges on hundreds of Indian blogs are a testimony of the trust bloggers pose on us.

Our hearty congratulations on your maintaining a quality blog, and we wish that your blog reaches new heights.

Best wishes!

IndianTopBlogs team


1. If you have any reservations about your blog's inclusion in the Directory, do email us and we’d remove your blog from our listing.

2. If you feel like, do place ITB badge on your blog. It is purely voluntary but we are sure it will add value to your blog in terms of reputation, popularity and position on search engines.

3. We have started a blogging community in Google Plus, with a few members to start with. We intend to make this community a place to exchange ideas about the craft of blogging. The Indian blogging community will benefit if you agree to join the G+ community page. Joining is very simple: Kindly go to the URL given below, join / sign in to Google Plus and click on 'ask to join'.

4. We are posting this message here as we could not find your email ID on the blog. Or did we miss it?

Anonymous said...

Hi! I could have sworn I've been to your blog before but after looking at some of the posts I realized it's new to me.
Anyhow, I'm certainly delighted I came across it and I'll be
bookmarking it and checking back often!

Also visit my homepage;